On Newsstands Now
The August 2010 issue of DownBeat highlights winners of our 58th Annual Critics Poll, including Joe Lovano, Muhal Richard Abrams, Baby Dodds, Chick Webb, Philly Joe Jones, Billy Eckstine, Keith Jarrett with Charlie Haden, Darcy James Argue, Vijay Iyer and dozens more.




Subscriber Login
DB Shop
Manage your subscription, Give a gift subscription
or shop for DownBeat
T-shirts, hats, back issues and more!

Sign up for our
Email Newsletter



33rd Annual Student
Music Awards
Now Online!


College Student
Digital DownBeat Subscription

Jazz 101
An abridged guide to the
rich music we call jazz.


Litchfield Jazz Festival

Telluride Jazz Festival

Featured CDs


For All We Know
by José James & Jef Neve



Pleased To Meet You
by Oliver Jones & Hank Jones


Princeton
Record
Exchange

Browse a huge selection of Jazz Records, used CDs featuring Jazz CDs & used DVDs at one of the largest Record Stores. Sell us your Jazz Vinyl, Jazz DVDs & CDs. Paying Top $ Since 1980 for Jazz LPs: Blue Note, Prestige, Mosaic, Impulse & more. Join us every Record Store Day

Wayne Shorter's "Creativity and Change"
An Exclusive Online Extra

by Wayne Shorter —  12/12/1968

Tenor saxophonist/composer Wayne Shorter first came to prominence with Art Blakey, with whom he played from 1959–1963. Since 1964, he has been a member of Miles Davis’ group. His most recent recordings under his own name are The All-Seeing Eye (Blue Note) and Adam’s Apple (Blue Note). He won the 1962 DownBeat Critics Poll Talent Deserving of Wider Recognition award as a composer.

Art. Art as a competitive thing among artists. I’ve been wondering how it has come about that art is, in fact, a competitive thing among artists. I wonder if artists choose to compete among themselves, or are they goaded, pushed or lured into it as a result of the makeup of this particular society? I wonder if a young musician, hearing another musician, has an instinctive desire to compete with this other musician or instead to join forces and compare notes? I wonder if the two of them were to get together and compare notes, and their notes were appraised by a third party, the critic, would these two artists be so influenced by what the third party says that they would strive to compete with one another to please the critic? In addition, the critic speaks to a fourth party, the public, and in pleasing the critic do you please the public?

I wonder if a poll or a contest is valid to give artists an incentive to create, to go on, or to run the mile in less than a minute. Is art an art or a sport? I think polls, awards and Oscars come right out of the school system—the star you get on your paper, the A B C D mark. If we could rid of the stigma that grading over such a long period of time has produced, I think we might have a clearer idea of what a person does when he is creating something. For instance, if a person wins first place in a category in the arts through a voting system, and he feels good about it, is he actually going to create or merely perpetuate the poll system?

It’s hard to get away from voting or polls all the way, because, if you’re going to play for an audience, the applause is the same thing in miniature size. Some people even consider applause as greater than a citation or trophy. Applause is gratifying to me and a lot of other musicians. Some musicians would deny it, but I know how they feel inside. I cannot say truthfully that lack of applause is not gratifying for me, because I can’t say that lack of applause means lack of recognition. That has happened to me quite a bit, especially when I first started out. Even now it happens sometimes, but then when I come down from the bandstand, someone will come up and say something profound about the whole set, not just about me. This one person sounds like he’s speaking for the whole audience, and he might say, "That was a deep set—a lot of thought going on." I think in that sense he was trying to say that there was no room for applause—they didn’t want to disturb the essence of the moment.

Does a person create because of recognition by a large body, and, if he is recognized, does he stop creating? I wonder if any artist can grade himself, using himself as his own ruler? Maybe that has to be taught. I’ve rarely had a teacher who said, "I’m going to teach you to grade yourself against yourself, use yourself as your own incentive force." You can draw power, drive, from yourself, from nature and not necessarily from another person. It’s hard to do, but once you know what it is and you start to reach for it, it’s really something. If anyone has seen 2001: A Space Odyssey, it’s like reaching for that black monolith, that symbol of Why and What and Where. If you’re curious enough about yourself, you don’t have too much time to be curious about what the next person is doing. You don’t try to compete with something superficial and exterior, a "keeping up with the Joneses" idea. I think that if artists learned to use themselves as their own ruler, then audiences would have to learn to do this too. When they go to see Broadway p

About  |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact
Copyright © 2010 Maher Publications. All rights reserved.
DownBeat is an internationally registered trademark of Maher Publications.